
Luc & Jean-Pierre Dardenne, Rosetta, 1999
Didn't enjoy this one as much as L'Enfant, though "enjoy" is hardly the word to describe the dreary drizzle and the rusting blast furnaces of the Dardennes' miserable Belgian hometown Seraing. The trademark almost continual handheld camerawork becomes seriously oppressive after about 15 minutes, presumably intentionally so – one longs for more structured shots, or at least a little perspective: how about zooming out a bit so we can see the full horror of the "Grand Canyon" trailer park where Rosetta lives with her deadbeat alcoholic mother? It's a dreadfully bleak affair, for sure, with just the faintest glimmer of hope at the end, and though I've seen it compared to Varda's Vagabond and Bresson's Mouchette, I don't think it's as good as either, not that the comparison makes much sense: Sandrine Bonnaire in the Varda is clearly opting out of society, while Emilie Dequenne's Rosetta is doing everything she can to be part of it. Mouchette is another grimly fatalist kettle of fish altogether, of course. The other names that come to mind when talking "gritty social(ist) realism" are Loach and Leigh, but while the Dardennes are clearly proud card-carrying socialists, they neither adopt Loach's vaguely sentimental portrayal of the working class nor indulge in Leigh's at times ridiculous class stereotypes. A bit more dialogue wouldn't have gone amiss, though.



















