Once again the hoax question... why is it that people feel so worried about being taken for a ride? Having swapped a good few emails with Naoshima I know he is serious, though humour certainly plays a part in some elements of the encadre releases.William Hutson wrote:i didn't mean to be so harsh. it's easy to forget sometimes that a lot of the artists we talk about have an audience comprising IHM posters and... well, that's about it. and there aren't enough of us to make a hoax worthwhile..
Regarding this new release, I was very tired last night and should have waited until today to post about it as I sound above like I am mocking it, which I certainly shouldn't be. I also mistook the Objective 1/2 piece for the Objective 4/4 score, as Yi corrected me on earlier. Apologies for that.
As for the disc, well this is the most difficult to get anything from yet I think. So far I haven't found anything of worth to take from three of the pieces, but I am enjoying trying. The Objective 1/2 piece is by some way the best thing on the disc, patches of organ-like sound pulsing softly but full of tremors split apart by long silences in a very Malfattiesque way.
I think Jon's assessment of the Encadre guys as trying to find their voice right now is correct. I find what they are doing very interesting, if not musically enthralling. Naoshima has a virtually silent but very enjoyable duo recording with Jason Kahn due out some time in the future on the windsmeasure label that is more in line with his music with Totsuka on the first two Encadre discs. Regarding the two Septet recordings, yes the second disc has more ambient room sound, passing traffic etc, and a little more instrumental sound, but I personally prefer the studio disc for the reasons I wrote a year ago here: http://www.thewatchfulear.com/?p=96








